Thursday, December 4, 2008

The Browns Table: Indianapolis Ineptitude


Welcome to The Browns Table, a season-long look at the 2008 season for the Cleveland Browns from the point of view of the Browns fans here on Bleacher Report.

This discussion is not just meant for the contributing Browns fans. Please feel free to comment on any of the questions or any of our answers below.

We welcome any comments and an open discussion about the Browns below. If you would like a seat at the table leave me a note on my profile and we will try and get you in the rotation.

As always thanks to Browns fans Samantha Bunten and The Coop for their contributions this week.

The guys and gals review another disappointing performance by the Browns’ offense, discuss the RB and QB situations and weigh in on the latest Browns controversy in soap opera land. Let’s talk Browns football.

Another game, another touchdown-less performance. Romeo Crennel said the gameplan "worked" even though they lost. What did you think of the offensive gameplan?

Samantha Bunten:
What gameplan? Seriously, the only way I would say this alleged gameplan worked is if the purpose was to eat up possession time without actually accomplishing anything. Crennel is just rearranging deck chairs on the Titanic, so to speak. I understand the need for the head coach to remain positive, but maybe it's time we just call a spade a spade and acknowledge that absolutely nothing the Browns do is working.

The Coop:
If I strain my eyes really hard, I can maybe see Romeo's point. The Browns moved the sticks won the time-of-possession battle, thereby keeping the normally-explosive Colts offense off the field.

But to say the gameplan "worked" is really a stretch. I mean, they scored 6 points on two field goals for crying out loud. In fact, other than the first two drives, they really only threatened to score one other time, and that resulted in a missed field goal.

Once again, the play-calling was way too predictable. Just because they wanted to establish the run doesn’t mean they should have ran it eight times in a row or on virtually every early-down situation.

And then when they decided to throw, almost everything was underneath. They hardly took any shots down the field, and the entire offense suffered as a result. With no downfield threats, Indy’s defense was able to play the run more aggressively and force the Browns to make plays, which we all know has been a challenge this year.

Jeff Smirnoff:
The premise was sound against a strong Colts offense. Posses the ball and minimize the Colts’ opportunities. That being said, to just posses the ball without being aggressive once you were sustaining a drive and not taking chances gives you no opportunity to win. Once the Browns got into Colts territory the offense became so conservative they were lucky to even get field goal attempts. The basis of the strategy was sound but the way they went about it was unbelievable.

Jamal Lewis asked for the ball and got it 24 times. He only gained 77 yards (3.2 average), however. How do you think Lewis should be used for the rest of this season and beyond?

Samantha Bunten:
While I acknowledge that Lewis was spectacularly unproductive on Sunday, I'm not sure we should be picking on him individually any more than anyone else. I'm glad he asked for the ball. It's nice to see someone on this squad is still willing to show some initiative even as the team continues to implode. Overall, what I might take from this is proof that Lewis needs some better blocking to assist him. He put up good numbers for the Browns last year, and I think he can do it again.

The Coop:
I will say this: running the ball is the only chance the Browns have of winning. Ken Dorsey isn’t going to beat anyone with his arm. So, for the remainder of 2008, the Browns have to pound Jamal when they can and then use Harrison and Wright more for a change-of-pace.

Lewis is a vital component of the Browns and needs to be treated as such going forward. People who want to get rid of Lewis because they think he is too old or think he’s lost a step are ignoring some very important facts and are not looking at the situation objectively.

Even in the last two games, Lewis has shown burst and power, ripping off some nice runs and also fighting for tough yards. Isn’t it possible that predictable play-calling and the absence of a downfield passing game might have something to do with his inability to dominate?

Jeff Smirnoff:
He should start and get 15-20 carries a game but not at the expense of getting Jerome Harrison and Josh Cribbs some touches on offense. Lewis is slowing down but he can still be an effective back if used properly. Harrison and Cribbs can keep the defense off balance, and are explosive runners, so getting them more involved will take the focus off of Lewis and hopes open up the power running game some.

Derek Anderson is now out for the season with a sprained MCL. What are the ramifications of having both Brady Quinn and Anderson out for the season?

Samantha Bunten:
Quinn and Anderson were both largely ineffective in their respective stints at the helm. Thus, I doubt losing both will really hurt the Browns all that much. I hate to challenge the universe's sense of irony by asking, "what could be worse?", but really, could things really be any more of a mess with Dorsey as the Browns QB?

The Browns season is over anyway, so even if Dorsey were to cost us a game or two, it won't make much difference overall. The one thing that makes this such a disappointment is that we did not get a chance to see if Quinn, finally given a series of consecutive starts, could step up and be the guy he was supposed to be when we drafted him. As per usual, we wait till next year.

The Coop:
Well, obviously, the injuries are troubling because no one knows how they will handle the rehab and recovery. I’d think Quinn would be okay because it doesn’t seem as serious, but the injury is on his throwing hand and who knows if it will limit his throwing ability. For Anderson, it’s much scarier because knee injuries are just never good. And the guy wasn’t mobile to begin with.

Quinn will be mainly hurt by not being able to gain valuable actual-game experience. There’s no substitution for facing “live bullets.” Allowing him to start the last half of the season would have given him a good foundation to build on heading into 2009. Now, he’s practically still a rookie.

As for Anderson, the bigger impact may be felt by the Browns as an organization. He now has virtually no trade value, because no one will want “damaged goods.” So, although I generally like DA, the Browns’ are more or less stuck with him until he plays out his contract or is released.

Jeff Smirnoff:
For Brady Quinn it is five games lost against quality opponents that you can accurately evaluate him for the future. Now you are forced to evaluate him based on three games, one healthy, and ten plays last year. Not a large data sample.

For Derek Anderson it is an opportunity lost to prove his worth to another team, prove to the Browns that he can still be their quarterback or increase his trade value. Now not only has he had a poor 2008 but he is also damaged goods without an opportunity to get back out there and show he is healthy.

Cue the Ken Dorsey Experience. Dorsey gets the start at QB for the rest of the year with Josh Cribbs serving as back-up. How should the Browns approach the QB position for the last 4 games?

Samantha Bunten:
It is a shame Winslow is injured - it would have been interesting to see if Dorsey and Winslow could rekindle some of the chemistry that made them a solid combination during their days at the University of Miami. That aside, I'm not sure this situation merits a change in approach to the position. The Browns have not had the luxury of relying on the strength of their quarterback all season, so they are used to having to look for other ways to succeed. Also, signing Gradkowski was a smart move - if anything happens to Dorsey, I don't really want to see Cribbs in the QB slot.

The Coop:
We now know that Bruce Gradkowski will be the backup. Thank goodness for that. The notion of Josh Cribbs playing QB is really silly. Cribbs in one of my favorite players, but the guy has no NFL experience at QB and hasn’t taken any reps in practice, nor has he been involved in quarterback meetings in Berea. How could anyone expect him to run the offense? Furthermore, putting him at QB takes away the Browns' best special teams player – offensively AND defensively – and reduces their options at the already-thin wideout position.

Dorsey deserves to finish the season as the starter because he knows the offense better than anyone on the roster. There’s a reason he’s a third-stringer, but the Browns weren’t exactly lighting up with the other two guys, so the Browns should just run him out there and hope for the best. Bet he wishes his first start as a Brown was coming against Denver (like Quinn) or Cincinnati (like Anderson) and not Tennessee!

Jeff Smirnoff:
Ken Dorsey should be the quarterback with a healthy dose of Josh Cribbs in the “Flash Package” as the Browns call it. You can not expect a guy, who already has to know all his special teams assignments and receiver routes, to come in and learn the entire playbook for a QB perspective in four weeks. Not going to happen. It also will decrease his effectiveness on special teams.

Dorsey is not going to light it up but at least he is a veteran who has some starting experience, albeit three seasons ago. Use Cribbs to keep the defense off balance but don’t expect him to come in and play quarterback in a standard capacity in any way, shape or form.

Controversy of the Week: Some of the faithful at Cleveland Browns Stadium cheered Derek Anderson's injury. Your thoughts on the fans taking their angst out on DA?

Samantha Bunten:
It is never, NEVER acceptable fan behavior to cheer for an injury to a member of your own team. Ever. I find this sort of behavior classless, disloyal, and flat out despicable. It reminds me of fans applauding when Tim Couch got a concussion a few years ago. I hated Couch as much as anyone, but I don't think a good fan should ever delight in an injury to a member of his team.

The Coop:
There’s no question that cheering because a player is injured is classless and disgusting.

But the thing that bothers me the most about this incident is that it’s just another occurrence in an all-too-familiar series of contemptible behavior by Browns fans. Since coming back in ’99, Browns fans have managed to cheer injuries to not one but two quarterbacks, litter the field with beer bottles and other debris, enter into email confrontations with members of the front office, and even run onto the field during a game.

I’ve always believed the Browns have the best, most loyal and passionate fans of any professional sports franchise. My friends, family and other bloggers here on B/R reaffirm those thoughts frequently. But when there are a couple of losers who act in these deplorable ways, it’s impossible for anyone else to see how great the majority of Browns fans truly are, and it personally embarrasses me.

Jeff Smirnoff:
I was at the game. It wasn’t all or most of the fans doing it but that doesn’t make it right at all. To boo any player when they are injured is just classless. I understand the fans are upset and frustrated at the Browns performance this season but that doesn’t give you Card Blanche to celebrate the injury to someone, let alone your own team.

It’s always the few people who do it that give the rest of the people a bad name but it doesn’t change the fact that it just is the wrong thing to do. Very disappointing indeed.

Sunday, November 30, 2008

Browns Lose Second Straight Game... and QB


On a miserable, rainy day on the shores of Lake Erie the Cleveland Browns put up another miserable performance, losing to the Indianapolis Colts 10-6.

They also likely lost beleaguered quarterback Derek Anderson for the season with a sprained MCL. Two weeks, two crappy performances, two quarterbacks done for the season.

Let the Ken Dorsey Experience begin. Dorsey will be taking the snaps next week against the Tennessee Titans and for the foreseeable future unless Anderson has a miraculous recovery.

As is with the 2008 the Browns their basic strategy was good but their implementation was awful. Run the ball, possess the ball and keep the potent Colts’ offense off the field. The Browns were able to do just that but whenever they got into the red zone they got ultra conservative and settled for field goals instead of touchdowns.

That philosophy had a chance to work with the normally porous Browns defense holding the Colts at bay, and without an offensive touchdown, but it was the offense that allowed the defense’s effort to be for naught.

With the Browns leading 6-3 midway through the fourth quarter Dwight Freeney beat Browns’ left tackle Joe Thomas on a bull rush and knocked the ball free from Anderson’s hands. Robert Mathis then scooped the ball up and rumbled 37 yards for the decisive score and a 10-6 Indianapolis victory.

The loss did spoil what was a good day for a Browns defense that held the Colts to just three points on offense. It was the first time since 2002, once again versus the Browns, that the Peyton Manning led Colts were held without an offensive touchdown.

Manning was 15 for 21 on the afternoon, but on for 125 yards and two interceptions. Joseph Addai and Dominick Rhodes were held to 92 yards on 26 carries. Struggling Browns’ corners Eric Wright and Brandon McDonald held their own against Reggie Wayne and Marvin Harrison whom totaled only seven catches on the afternoon.

Wright recovered an Addai fumble on the opening play of the game and McDonald picked off Manning on a ball intended for Wayne on the Colts opening series of the second half. Sean Jones picked Manning on the final play of the first half.

But in the end it didn’t matter much as on a day that the defense showed up to play the offense did not. The plays the offense ran were designed more not to lose the game than to try and win it. That is what losing teams do, par for the course for the 2008 Cleveland Browns.

Wednesday, November 26, 2008

The Brady Quinn Conundrum

The Cleveland Browns disappointing 2008 got even more disappointing with the news that quarterback Brady Quinn would be placed on Injured Reserve with a damaged tendon in the index finger on his throwing hand. Currently, there is no decision on whether or not Quinn will require surgery to repair the finger.

Quinn originally injured the finger in the Week 11 Monday night tilt against the Buffalo Bills. It was in that game where he fractured the tip of his right, index finger. He was cleared to play in this past Sunday's game against the Houston Texans where he was pulled by head coach Romeo Crennel in favor of deposed starter Derek Anderson.

You have to give credit to Quinn for playing through the injury, but in hindsight the decision turned out to be poor. It now leaves the Browns in a pickle when it comes to their quarterback situation in 2009.

Quinn only was able to muster three starts. He had a great statistical debut, but a loss, in Week 10 versus the Denver Broncos when he benefitted from a porous Broncos defense and solid game plan.

He followed that up with a below average game against Buffalo where he was not great statistically but was able to make plays when he needed to in leading the Browns to a victory. Sunday, against Houston, he had a very poor game before being benched in favor of Anderson.

The remainder of 2008 was mostly about developing Brady Quinn to see if he could be the man for 2009. Now that evaluation process is put on hold. The problem that presents the Browns is that they are going to have to make a decision on Quinn with very little data to analyze.

The Browns pretty much know what they have in Anderson. A tall, strong armed quarterback who can make all the throws but struggles mightily with consistency and decision making. When the pressure is off Anderson is at his best. When the pressure is on Anderson is at his worst.

The Browns have had 11 starting quarterbacks in the ten years since their reincarnation and desperately needs to stabilize the position. Losing the time to evaluate Quinn hurts in that endeavour.

Do they commit to him with only three pro starts under his belt? Do they try and have he and Anderson coexist for another season? Do they have an open competition next year in Trainign Camp?

It all leads to a giant conundrum for the Cleveland Browns.

For now they can only hope that Quinn heals up and is 100% for OTAs in the spring and that Anderson can play well enough in the last five games of the season to increase his trade value if they decide to go that route. But for now, all that Cleveland is left with is another disappointment.

Tuesday, November 25, 2008

The Browns Table: A Texas Sized Letdown

Welcome to The Browns Table, a season-long look at the 2008 season for the Cleveland Browns from the point of view of the Browns fans here on Bleacher Report.

This discussion is not just meant for the contributing Browns fans. Please feel free to comment on any of the questions or any of our answers below.

We welcome any comments and an open discussion about the Browns below. If you would like a seat at the table leave me a note on my profile and we will try and get you in the rotation.

As always thanks to Browns fans Eric Lawhead and Michael Taylor for their contributions this week.

The guys lament another disappointing performance by the team and discuss where the Browns go from here. Let’s talk Browns football.

The Browns fell to the Houston Texans, 16-6, on Sunday. The performance was bad to put it nicely. What was the worst part of the Browns performance?

Eric Lawhead:
Quarterback play. When your two quarterbacks combine to go 13-32 with 0 TD and 3 INT, it means bad day and worse result. The Texans only scored 16 points. The Browns with the offensive firepower they are capable of, they should be able to beat a team scoring 16 points. They got a whopping 95 yards rushing as well. Not good against a team with a pretty bad back up in Sage Rosenfels.

Jeff Smirnoff:
It was the fact that the Browns could do nothing against a bad football team who was sporting one of the worst defenses in the NFL and a turnover prone offense. It was a horrible performance in all phases of the game. This team fails to learn anything from previous weeks and continues to spin its wheels. The Texans gave the Browns plenty of opportunities to stay in and ever take over the game and the Browns just gave it right back to them each time.

Michael Taylor:
I don't even know where to start...do we begin by looking at how Sage Rosenfels looked like a Pro Bowler, how Kellen Winslow disappeared, how Braylon Edwards dropped a million passes, or how Brady was benched to see if Derek had a hot hand today?

To me, just the entire second half of the game was an embarrassment. There was no fire in the team. It was sloppy, and if the Texans could have "finished" the game, it would have been a route.

Brady Quinn did not play well and was replaced by Derek Anderson. Should Quinn have been pulled despite is rough day?

Eric Lawhead:
Quinn should have never started. He has a fracture in a pretty important finger in his throwing hand. A broken pinky kept Tony Romo out for 3 weeks! Why would you play a guy who is needed to manage the game and throw crisp precise passes to keep the defense away from the ball? Anderson should have started and at least gave them a starting chance to throw the ball against a bad Texans pass defense.

Jeff Smirnoff:
Absolutely not. Anderson should have been pulled against Cincinnati and Washington where he was performing much worse than Quinn did versus Houston. It just shows the lack of leadership on the team from the owner to the GM to the head coach and the double standards exist. Was Quinn having a bad game? Yes and that’s being kind, but you have to see how he can develop and overcome adversity.

Michael Taylor:
At first I was ok with the change, thinking that the broken finger had something to do with the change. Though, just seconds later, we saw BQ upset on the sideline that he was pulled, obviously his finger was not the issue. Because of that and his comments after the game, I don't understand the move. How is he supposed to learn to work through adversity in this league if his coach doesn't show any confidence in him? Talk about a slap in the face. Derek makes mistakes for half a season, and a couple of passes in the third quarter for picks and Quinn is pulled. The change has been made, Quinn is the future. Let him learn and play.

Braylon Edwards continued to drop passes at an alarming rate. Kellen Winslow had his obligatory offensive pass interference penalty. Which of the two has been the bigger disappointment this year?

Eric Lawhead:
Edwards is more disappointing this season. Everyone is going to say Winslow, because of his attitude and what not. But with what kind of number Edwards put up last season, it is painful to watch him not produce. Now to give him the benefit of the doubt, the offense, mainly the quarterback play has not helped him this season. Anderson is not the same Anderson that gave him the opportunity he had last season. It's just frustrating to watch him not produce when he's given any opportunity.

Jeff Smirnoff:
On the field, Edwards. Off the field, Winslow. Edwards seems to lose focus on a week to week basis. I still think many of his troubles are mental and not physical. The drops can be cured, the question is does he have the mental toughness to overcome them. Winslow has been plagued by injuries this year but the return of his loose lips after a quiet 2007 make me wonder if he really wants to be here.

Michael Taylor:
Braylon by far. I don't even know what to think of it anymore. As pointed out Sunday, he is running poor routes and is dropping passes at an alarming rate. He just looks lackadaisical out there. I just don't see the same guy that was a force last season. I wasn't expecting 16 TD's again, but I figured 1,000 yards and 8-10 TD's would have been a lock. That can still happen, but it will be very tough.

The Browns are now 4-7. The play-offs are pretty much impossible to attain. What should the goal for the team for the rest of 2008?

Eric Lawhead:
Develop Brady Quinn and fire Romeo Crennel now! Quinn is first and foremost. He needs to learn the system in the game. He needs to learn to make better decisions and learn what it takes to learn on the fly and be and NFL quarterback. Romeo on the other hand will just bring down any sense of talent on this team for the rest of the season. Fire him now, so they can work out a deal with Cowher and then ride the season out and fire Phil Savage and give it all to the Steeler-man himself.

Jeff Smirnoff:
Develop Brady Quinn to see if he is the franchise quarterback that this team sorely needs. See if some of the younger talent like Martin Rucker, Beau Bell, Jerome Harrison, etc. can be key pieces in building a foundation for next season. See how some of the younger veterans (i. e. Edwards and Winslow) handle themselves the rest of the year to see if they should be retained or traded.

Michael Taylor:
To me, I could care less how the remaining games go in the win-loss column. I just want to see this team go out, compete, and not make so many mistakes. I just want to see clean, competitive football. Not this sloppy, penalty-ridden, poor tackling, frustrating brand of football that we have witnessed this season.

The Browns also need to just let Brady play and play through tough situations. Everything was and is not going to be easy for him. He has to learn on the job while the pressure is off of him in terms of having to win games right now. Then based on how he does the Browns can then make a better decision in the off-season on what to do at the quarterback position.

E-mail Gate: Browns GM Phil Savage fired off a profane e-mail to a fan after the Buffalo game. What is your take on the situation as it came down?

Eric Lawhead:
Two sides to my take. First being the public figure Savage is. He should never write something like that. He should have just taken the e-mail and deleted it and forgot about it. There is no need to fire back at a fan they are the ones paying the money to see your team suffer. Second being the real person Savage is. That was human nature to do what he did. Most all of us, if we got an e-mail or letter going after the way we do our job and the company we are employed by, would fire right back at them. It's just the way most everyone is. We would defend our stance and our situation. The winning vote is the first, Savage is a public figure. He should have never done what he did. But it's over and he will not be employed by the Cleveland Browns for the 2009-2010 season.

Jeff Smirnoff:
It was totally unprofessional and embarrassing but it ultimately will not be the reason that he may lose his job at the end of the year. The fact that he even felt the urge to reply to that e-mail when he probably gets thousands of them every week is ridiculous. It’s just another blemish on the Browns organization as a whole. We are one of the laughingstocks of the NFL and have been since they returned.

Michael Taylor:
I think that this whole issue is just silly and simply a microcosm of what this season has become. Only the Browns could have such a ludicrous problem as this. While I do not appreciate what Savage did, as I believe a part of being in front office management is remaining professional in all facets of the job, I will not bash him for doing it. I would just hope in the future that he would not be reading such garbage in his email inbox. Why was he reading these emails anyway?

Sunday, November 23, 2008

Bumbling Browns Fall to Texans, 16-6

Breaking news, the 2008 Cleveland Browns are not a good football them. If anyone had any doubt of that or were holding on to faint play-off hopes were rudely awakened Sunday afternoon versus the Houston Texans.

Houston had not won a road game in over a calendar year but thanks to five Cleveland turnovers they were able to end that skid with a 16-6 victory in a contest that wasn’t that close.

The Texans took the opening kick-off and effortlessly drove 79 yards for a 7-0 lead. Journeyman back-up quarterback Sage Rosenfels picked apart the sieve-like Browns defense hitting receivers Andre Johnson and Kevin Walter at will.

Walter caught a 17 yard corner route for a touchdown burning much maligned cornerback Brandon McDonald for a 7-0 Texans. Rosenfels went 6-7 on the opening drive as the Texans ate up over eight minutes on their opening drive.

The Browns responded on their first drive of the afternoon in the only way they know how. A Kellen Winslow drop, a penalty and a Jamal Lewis fumble to give the ball back to the Texans. Rosenfels and Walter continue to hook-up over the middle of the field but the Browns defense managed to hold the Texans to a Kris Brown field goal.

The Browns dusted off running back Jerome Harrison on the next drive and managed to put a Phil Dawson on the board. Shaun Rogers blocked a Texans field goal to keep the game at 10-3 and the Dawson delivered another field goal to cut the lead to 10-6.

Former Brown Andre Davis returned the subsequent kick-off for a touchdown but it was called back for a holding penalty. No matter as Rosenfels once again found Johnson and Walter time and time again, including two fourth down conversions, and Brown poked through his second field goal for a 13-6 Houston advantage.

Then, in what could only be a sign of things to come later in the game, the Browns somehow muffed the ensuing allowing Brown to attempt a 56 yard field goal with one second left. Brown missed, but the fact that the Texans even had the opportunity was embarrassing.

The halftime score was 13-6 but the Texans had dominated the first half, holding the ball for almost 21 minutes. The Houston running game was held in check but Rosenfels was having a career day throwing the ball.

Cleveland went three and out to start the half but were given a lifeline when Rosenfels returned to his sometimes turnover prone form as Brodney Pool picked him off on the Texans opening drive. But Browns’ quarterback Brady Quinn returned the favor and the Texans turned the Browns second turnover into another Brown field goal and a 16-6 lead.

Quinn drove the Browns into the red zone but was picked off for the second time on an attempted slant to Braylon Edwards. The Texans were forced to punt for the first time in the game and Romeo Crennel sent in Derek Anderson at quarterback.

Some reports said Quinn was pulled due to reinjuring his index finger that he chipped a bone in last week. Others said Quinn was pulled due to performance and had some choice words at the decision.

If the later is true, it is a curious move as there were more than a handful of games where Anderson was not performing well and Romeo Crennel stuck with him rather than go to Quinn. Quinn was having a poor game, but the double standard that may have been in effect does raise a few eyebrows.

Anderson fared no better than Quinn as the Browns imploded from that point forward. Edwards continued to drop the football, Winslow got his obligatory offensive pass interference penalty and the normally reliable Dawson shanked a makeable field that could have cut the lead to 7.

Rosenfels teased the Cleveland faithful by throwing another pick to Browns’ safety Sean Jones that was returned into Houston territory. But Jamal Lewis missed a handoff from Anderson and the Browns committed their fifth turnover of the game and sealed their seventh loss of the season.

Any play-off hopes for the Browns are effectively done as the now sit at 4-7, 3-5 in the AFC and 1-3 in the AFC North. After going 7-1 at Cleveland Browns Stadium in 2007 the Browns are a lowly 1-5 at home in 2008.

The Browns continually fall flat on their faces after a win, this time falling to a 3-7 football team starting their back-up quarterback. They are now staring down another potential ten loss season which would be their sixth in the ten years since their reincarnation. Unfortunately, that make be the only realistic goal the team may have for the rest of 2008.

Wednesday, November 19, 2008

The Browns Table: A Buffalo Bailout

Welcome to The Browns Table, a season-long look at the 2008 season for the Cleveland Browns from the point of view of the Browns fans here on Bleacher Report.

This discussion is not just meant for the contributing Browns fans. Please feel free to comment on any of the questions or any of our answers below.

We welcome any comments and an open discussion about the Browns below. If you would like a seat at the table leave me a note on my profile and we will try and get you in the rotation.

As always thanks to Browns fans Samantha Bunten, The Coop, and the Dawgfather for their contributions this week.

The ladies and gents talk about Brady Quinn’s first NFL win, Braylon Scissor-hands, why they can tackle better than the Browns D and wax poetic about some Browns of years past…

…but for now let’s talk Browns football…

The Browns squeaked out a 29-27 win over the Bills on MNF notching Brady Quinn his first career victory. His numbers weren't good but what did you think of his performance?

Samantha Bunten:
I think he did fine. It would have been fantastic if Quinn had surprised us all with a breakout performance, but realistically speaking all he had to be was better than Derek Anderson, and for the most part, he was. After just two starts, I don't think we can make any accurate judgments on how Quinn will fare in the long run. For now, I would like to see him work on red-zone efficiency and spreading the ball around more.

The Coop:
I could not care less about statistics. Call me crazy, but I would dare to say that he played even better against Buffalo than he did against Denver. First of all, and most importantly, he got the win. He did what it took to manage the game efficiently and effectively. He did not turn the ball over, and he would have looked even better if the Browns’ so-called “star” receiver did not have stone hands. The Bills took away his favorite target in the Denver game (Kellen Winslow) and instead of trying to force the ball to him he distributed it around to his other receivers. He stood tall in the pocket, took some brutal hits, and showed poise, leadership, and confidence.

And he did all this against a much, much better defense in Buffalo, on the road, in less-than-ideal weather conditions. I’m starting to buy into the hype.

Dawgfather:
Very effective and very poised and cool. He didn't make any ill-advised throws or try to force anything. Overall another quality start.

Jeff Smirnoff:
Eff the numbers, he just looks like he belongs. For the second week in a row everything was organized and crisp. He made no mistakes and avoided the turnover, although he did come close a few times. He made the plays when he needs to make them. When the Bills scored he led the Browns down the field and answered. When he got the ball at the end of the game I had full confidence that he would lead them down for the go ahead score.

Quinn’s development this year should not be measured by statistics or by wins and losses (although the former would be nice). How his game continues to evolve, how he reacts and performs in every situation and how he adapts to the game are what is important. The Browns need to establish that he is their quarterback that will lead this team for the next decade. They have many more holes they need to fill and removing quarterback from that list is imperitive.

Braylon Edwards, and his hands, decided to make an appearance to the benefit of the team. What do you feel has contributed the most to his disappointing 2008?

Samantha Bunten:
Edwards just doesn't have his head or his heart in the game. He has lapses in concentration at critical moments, often appears to be afraid to take hits, and just can't deliver under pressure. His numbers are terrible against opponents in the division and he's averaging over 20 YPG less this year (57.6) than he was last year (80.6).

The most disturbing thing of all is that his numbers are very, very similar in games the Browns win to his numbers in games the Browns lose, indicating that his presence on the field really doesn't matter all that much.

The Coop:
Not enough Five Hour Energy. But seriously, I think it’s inconsistency as a result of lack of focus, intensity, and passion. You don’t often think of needing intensity to catch a football, but in the NFL, you need to be intense just lacing up your shoes.

I think his mind wanders as he starts to think about what his ESPN highlight will look like after he makes the catch. But he forgets that the most important part of the highlight is the physical act of making the catch.

The sad thing is, I seriously doubt whether he even cares enough to get better. When I see dropped passes out of him every single week, I have to wonder if he’s working hard enough in practice, staying after practice, and doing whatever it takes to get the job done when it counts for real.

Additionally, I’m sure he’s always been able to get by on raw ability, and he thinks things will come to him as easily in the NFL as it did through high school and college. It doesn't quite work that way.

Dawgfather:
Dropping key passes that could have helped the Browns win some games that they lost.

Jeff Smirnoff:
I think he came in a little full of himself in training camp and once he got hurt he lost his rhythm and timing. Somewhere along the way I also think he lost a little focus because 2007 was so easy and effortless. He has struggled to get it back and I think it is I his head. He looks a little lost at times, not just with the drops, but even on some catches he has to “double catch”. I still have faith he can be a money receiver, but he needs to get refocused and rededicated in the off-season and realize he has to continually work to stay at the top. He has the talent to do it, does he have the mind and discipline to do it?

The defense was once again plagued by poor tackling but did generate four turnovers. What does this unit have to do to play better on a consistent basis?

Samantha Bunten:
The defense shows flashes of greatness, but it never lasts more than a week. And despite generating 4 turnovers on Monday, they had a pretty poor showing overall. We've talked about stopping the run ad nausea all season. So far, no improvement has been made consistently. They also need to focus on consistently pressuring the quarterback and stopping short-yardage gains.

The Coop:
You said it already - tackle! I mean, watching the tackling display in the last three weeks is truly embarrasing. In addition to that, I think they need to work schemes that pressure the passer more consistently and effectively. They're not going to have the luxury of facing Trent Edwards every week. They've got to harrass the QB all day long.

You can't argue with their ability to get turnovers and, for the most part, they stayed away from the big play against Buffalo. These things must continue too.

Dawgfather:
Besides tackling, they lack fundamentals, they are often out of space, get blown off the ball by the opposing offensive line clearly need to wrap up better in the open field.

Jeff Smirnoff:
Get healthy and better talent. Robaire Smith has been on IR for most of the year. Sean Jones, Shaun Smith and Corey Williams are playing hurt. I have already gone on record lamenting the poor play of our linebacking core. The secondary is young and thin. Getting healthy in the front line will help but until the talent is upgraded in the back seven they will continue to struggle, bad tackling or not.

The Browns are now 4-6. They face a potent Houston Texans offense but Houston's defense is just as porous as the Browns'. What do you see in your crystal ball?

Samantha Bunten:
The Browns horrendous run defense will have trouble stopping Houston's offense, and should be particularly concerned about Texans' rookie Steve Slaton, who had a breakout game last week vs. the Colts. On the other side of the ball, our offense should be able to exploit Houston's weak, 17th ranked secondary.

The Browns have won 3 of 5 vs the Texans, so there is no glaring advantage there. However, Jamal Lewis absolutely owns Houston. In the last Browns-Texans meeting in 2007, Lewis had 29 carries for 134 yards, and if history is any indication, he'll come up big this Sunday as well.

The Coop:
Remember all the offense in the first Browns-Bengals game last year? You ain't seen nothin yet. If the weather is not a factor, it will be a track meet.

For Houston, Steve Slaton is probably going to break the all-time record for most yards in a single game. Brandon McDonald should also hope that Andre Johnson slips in the shower and breaks a leg, because if he thought Brandon Marshall was a beast, Andre Johnson will make Marshall look like Dennis Northcutt.

For the Browns, Jamal and Jerome should be able to run all day. The O-Line will have to keep BQ upright. Mario Williams can bring it, and I'm really excited to see the matchup between him and Joe Thomas. But if BQ has the time, he will find the open man.

Every possession is going to be critical because the team who wins the time of possession and has the ball last is going to win.

Dawgfather:
I see a 38-35 Browns shootout. I look for Andre Johnson to have a MONSTER game against our secondary and Steve Slaton to go buck-wild.

Jeff Smirnoff:
With their porous defense the Browns are going to have to put up around 30 points on a consistent basis to win games. Steve Slaton is just the type of back that gashes the Browns and Andre Johnson dwarfs anyone in our secondary. Sage Rosenfels is a sin-wave type of quarterback and if he is on, the Browns are in trouble. If not, it may be a replay of the Buffalo game. The Texans defense is not that good either so this has all the makings for a shoot-out.

Philosophical Question Du Jour: Phil Dawson hit 5 field goals including the game winning 56 yarder. He is the last remaining Brown from 1999. Who is the best Browns player since their reincarnation?

Samantha Bunten:
Over the years, many players have at times looked as though they might earn this distinction (Northcutt, William Green, Winslow, Lewis), but they all seemed to have the same problem our team has collectively this season: they just couldn't seem to show up for more than two weeks in a row. So far, I don't think anyone has earned the right to be called The Best. Here's hoping someone steps up soon.

The Coop:
You nailed it. It's Phil Dawson. In an organization full of inconsistency and drama from Day 1, he has been steady as a rock. The guy has made HUGE kicks time after time, and always shows up and does his job. He's reliable, and as a captain, I believe he is a leader who provides a great veteran presence.

I feel funny about naming a kicker, but it is what it is. With the minimal success that the Browns have had since '99 and the big ups and downs, it's probably more of an indictment of the organization than an endorsement of the player.

I'd love to say it's Kellen Winslow, but he's hardly been on the field in his time with the Browns and has disappeared at times. Joe Thomas? Second-year man, and too early to tell.

No doubt that the Browns have some other players who are close. I love Brodney Pool and Jamal Lewis. But they haven't done it for the Browns long enough or consistently enough to be considered.

Dawgfather:
Jamir Miller, at least he could tackle.

Jeff Smirnoff:
It’s Phil Dawson without question. He has been more than consistent (4th most accurate kicker in NFL history). He is one of the few clutch performers the Browns have had even going back to the win over the Appalachian Inbred in 1999. He has a flair for the dramatic a la the Gooseneck Field Goal and the Snow Game kicks. He has gotten better with each passing year and would be a Pro Bowl player by now if he had been playing for a team that regularly wins.

For those who are purists and will not accept a kicker it is Steve Heiden. Obtained for a 7th round pick, Heiden has been steady, a total team player and people often forget how good he is because of Kellen Winslow. Look at the two years that he filled in for Winslow. Those stats are pretty damn good, especially for a guy who had Jeff Garcia, Luke McNown, Kelly Holcomb, Trent Dilfer and Charlie Frye throwing to him.